As a nation, the United States has been discussing the rebuilding of the country’s infrastructure for over a decade. It has been a major part of campaign promises for both parties’ candidates in every election cycle. Anyone who travels abroad marvels at the modern airports in the Middle East, the highways of Europe and the clean energy infrastructure in the Far East. According to Citi research, our country’s infrastructure is underbuilt both on the “heavy” side (the American Society of Civil Engineers issues US infrastructure a “D+” grade ) and the “light” side (housing starts averaged 0.7 mm in 2010-19, well below the historical avg. of ~1.5mm) according to census info and The National Association of Home Builders.
Last year, this theme started getting its due, with two infrastructure-minded presidential candidates and housing construction beginning to return to historical levels. Covid temporarily threw a wrench in the works, but the theme only strengthened due to an enormous number of secular tailwinds – low interest rates, likely for several years, enormous amount of fiscal spending, “work from home” gaining traction, the rush to buy or rent second homes, the need to create jobs in the construction industry, to name a few.
While there is some recent choppiness around rate expectations, we ultimately do not see a path to a rapid increase in rates in the next three years. Further, a market now accustomed to lower terminal rates, and a very gradual pace of hikes, ultimately gives the Fed more flexibility in unwinding some of the extraordinary accommodation currently in place as there is less risk of a true “taper tantrum.” While rates tend to be the major factor in residential construction, the increasing “work from home” phenomenon, combined with the boom in people seeking second homes means more business for home enlargement and improvement, increased existing home sales, likely more single-family rentals, and increased “Fix and Flip” activity.
Some Supply Estimates (Based on Citi Research)
Based on Citi Research, in terms of housing starts, we expect single family to dominate (+11% Y/Y in ’21) while multi-family declines -10% Y/Y. The recovery of housing starts will continue into 2022 (est. 1.5mm), as inventories remain tight in an undersupplied market. Among other key assumptions, household density will tick down to around 2.08 adults per household in 2021, with population growth driving ~1.3mm new households, 85% of which are expected to be owner occupied (in-line with recent years). New single-family home sales will grow +13.3% Y/Y in ’21 while owner-built homes will remain flat (total single-family starts +11.1. Multifamily starts will decline -10.3% in ’21, leading to the forecast for total starts growth of +5.1% in ‘21.
The demand response that followed from Covid was almost the exact opposite of the industry’s experience in 2008, with lockdowns pulling forward demand and low rates boosting affordability. Some reasons: 1) Underbuilt housing stock which preceded the pandemic (housing inventories remain at historic lows following a decade of under-building; 2) Millennial demographic shift (higher than average birth rates during the ’45-’60 period as well as the ’85-’95 period are now translating into Millennials entering the market for the first time and Boomers retiring and potentially downsizing); 3) De-urbanization that began before the pandemic (Covid has accelerated de-urbanization and Sun Belt migration though the trend can be traced at least back to the 2017 Tax Cuts & Jobs Act, which capped SALT deductions); 4) Most importantly, low rates, which are here to stay for some time. This info comes from the following sources: Bloomberg, Investopedia, and The Hill.
Several leading indicators show that activity remains strong at various stages of the home buying process, from online searches to real estate showings to mortgage applications. The Mortgage Bankers Association’s (MBA) seasonally adjusted purchase index was up double digits Y/Y for the 32nd consecutive week (week ended 1/1/2021), although on a sequential basis, the index has seen some choppiness since the start of June.
Consistent with the recovery in mortgage applications, real estate viewings continue to accelerate. Following 5 years of overbuilding heading into the 2008-09 downturn, the industry underbuilt for 13 consecutive years coming out of “the Great Recession.”
Supply/demand remains favorable with supply of existing homes near all-time lows. Furthering favorable supply/demand characteristics, many potential sellers of existing homes took their properties off the market due to Covid fears.
The single-family rental (SFR) market is having its moment. While other asset classes like retail and office have stumbled during the coronavirus pandemic, the SFR market has thrived, thanks to ultra-low interest rates and occupancy in rentals remaining steady compared to pre-Covid. Inventory has been tight and demand has been tighter. A recent study by Mynd found that Milwaukee, Memphis and Detroit are expected to attract a lot of activity for SFR investors in 2021 as home appreciation in those cities jumped between 2019 to 2020. Other cities like Houston and Charlotte, N.C., have remained attractive.
Lumber, Copper, and other materials are showing some weakness early in 2021. One should largely look past this inevitable demand air pocket in 1H ’21 as project delays and cancellations continue. As a 2H ’21 recovery materializes and the Biden administration proposes infrastructure stimulus, we expect construction materials to go higher. In general, “heavy” construction materials will outperform “light” materials” more linked to rehab projects, as these have already been in demand right through 2020. This information is via: Transportation Today News and Investopedia.
All indicators of supply and demand show a bullish picture for homebuilding, home rehab and renting (SFR) and selling activities. There are secular trends that support this view, trends likely to last for several years. This should support prices of not only residences, but also infrastructure activities and construction materials, especially “heavy” materials used in large projects.
NOTE: The experts at Bankrate recently compiled a list of the five states with the strongest housing economies during the coronavirus based on home appreciation, job growth, cost of living and taxes. It breaks down the financial incentives and projections of these desirable markets and compares them to the alternatively slower housing markets in the country. Check out the article here: https://www.bankrate.com/mortgages/mortgage-rates/#housing-heat-index